India finally ratifies UN Trafficking Protocol
After an eleven-year delay, India finally ratified the UN protocol on human trafficking on 5 May 2011, along with conventions against internationally organised crime and corruption.
Known as the Palermo Protocol, the Protocol to Prevent, Suppress and Punish Trafficking in Persons, Especially Women and Children, supplementing the United Nations Convention against Transnational Organised Crime, was adopted by a UN resolution in 2000 and signed by India in 2002. The Protocol is significant because it gave the first comprehensive definition of human trafficking, and required countries to criminalise the practice, and to adopt legislation to translate the Protocol’s obligations into national law.
Year-on-year, the annual Trafficking in Persons Report has highlighted that India had failed to ratify the Protocol, as had a recent UN report[1]. The concern has been that India lacked a comprehensive definition of human trafficking to provide a common platform for the different Indian states to use in legislation and enforcement. The UN report also expressed concern that there was a shortfall in gender sensitivity. Trafficking has not been regarded as an organised crime, so provisions relevant to such crime are not utilised in enforcement. Also, legislation and enforcement has often failed to distinguish between the trafficker and the victims, so survivors are often punished rather than perpetrators. The hope is that now these will begin to be put right.
Ratification welcomed by NGOs
Experts in child issues agree that the government announcement is a good thing. For example, in a news release, R.S. Chaurasia of child rights NGO Bachpan Bachao Andolan said: “This ratification is a shot in the arm for all the anti-human trafficking activists like us as the lack of a comprehensive legislation and policy in India has often been the reason for the lack of law enforcement and knowledge on the issue.”
“Ratification of this convention means that it is now binding upon India to develop a law that conforms to the International Convention and its provisions. Often, the criminal gangs involved in large-scale kidnappings, abductions and forced labour of children go scot-free as the laws in the country are more biased towards prosecuting the employers or pimps in case of prostitution. But traffickers of forced labour will now come within the purview of the law in the country,” he added.
Corruption fears
The lack of effective prosecutions and enforcement has been blamed at least in part on corruption, so the announcement made at the same time that India has also ratified the UN Convention Against Corruption has been welcomed. Prime Minister Manmohan Singh said “the ratification of the United Nations Convention Against Corruption is a reaffirmation of our government’s commitment to fight corruption”. Press reports highlight accusations against various sitting politicians of scams running into billions of dollars, and the end of the eleven-year wait for ratification has been put down to domestic pressure. However, the constant threat of India being downgraded to Tier 3 in the annual Trafficking in Persons report may also have had a bearing.
Dr Joseph D’souza, International President of Dalit Freedom Network, comments, “We welcome this move by the Indian government. Now we are looking for a significant improvement in enforcement and victim care as words are translated into action. Our concern is for millions of Dalits who are being exploited. They make up to 90% of all those trafficked or in bonded labour in India. We value the role of the international community not only in supporting our on-the-ground efforts to address trafficking in India, but also in encouraging the authorities to move toward more comprehensive measures and more effective action.”
Read the British government's response to India's ratification of the protocol.
[1] Responses to Human Trafficking in Bangladesh, India, Nepal and Sri Lanka (UNODC/UN.GIFT: 2011)
Latest News Articles
-
Dalit population reaches 300 million in India +
Figures from the recently released 2011 census in India show that Dalits and Tribals total more than 300 million and now exceed a quarter of the national population. More than half of Dalits live in just five states - Uttar Pradesh (over one fifth of Dalits), West Bengal, Bihar, Tamil Nadu and Andhra Pradesh. In addition to the North East states, there are significant Tribal populations in Madhya Pradesh, Maharashtra, Odisha (Orissa), Rajasthan and Gujurat. Dalits and Tribals – categorised as scheduled castes and scheduled tribes by the Indian government – both fall outside of India’s caste system. There appears to be a correlation between areas with high populations of Dalits and Tribals and hotspots for human trafficking and bonded labour, supporting the evidence that the vast majority… Read More
-
Indian parliament approves tough new laws on human trafficking +
Both houses of the Indian parliament have now approved tough new laws on sexual violence against women, including human trafficking, in the aftermath of the gang-rape and subsequent death of a 23 year-old medical student in Delhi last December. Following protests on the streets of India and worldwide media coverage, a report by a committee led by former Chief Justice Verma recommended sweeping changes to Indian law and to rehabilitation procedures. The Indian President, Pranab Mukherjee, took up most of the legal recommendations in an emergency temporary law – Criminal Law (Amendment) Ordinance 2013 - on 3 February, however this had to be ratified by Parliament within 6 weeks. The Criminal Law (Amendment) Bill 2013 was passed by the Lok Sabha (lower house) on 19 March, and… Read More
-
Delhi High Court criticises lax approach of police to human trafficking +
The High Court of Delhi expressed serious concerns over the casual approach taken by police in the Indian capital and in the state of Orissa (Odisha) over a case of human trafficking dating back to 2010. Dalit Freedom Network UK reported on the case and the action taken by Indian colleagues leading to the rescue of Sunita* from abusive domestic servitude. Sunita’s sister, Mina*, was trafficked from Orissa at the same time, but is still missing. Sunita and Mina (aged 15 and 18 when trafficked) were from a Tribal family, displaced by sectarian violence and living in extreme poverty. Like Dalits, Tribals (Adivasis) fall outside of India’s rigid caste system, and face discrimination, oppression and abuse. This along with the resulting poverty makes them very… Read More
-
Get together to help free India's Dalits! +
With new Dalit Freedom Action Groups getting off the ground, and an increasing number of enquiries, there has never been a better time for starting an action group! If you think action groups are all about agendas, setting up a committee, endless meetings, open-ended commitment, then think again! Not only is it a bigger and better way of making an impact for Dalit Freedom, but there are lots of different approaches including one that’s bound to suit your personality and situation. Dalit Freedom Action Groups can come in all shapes and sizes, for example: Two or three people who meet up anyway, but occasionally plan an activity to raise awareness A network of people who you can call on to help with particular fundraising event… Read More
-
Dalit women celebrate empowerment on International Women’s Day +
Every year in March, Dalit women in India gather to attend one of Dalit Freedom Network's International Women's Day celebrations. This year events are taking place in four different locations and each one is expected to attract hundreds of women. The festivities typically include speeches, dance performances, and awards for vocational training graduates. Women from our Self-Help (LAMP) Groups often arrive wearing matching saris, demonstrating the pride and solidarity they get from their participation in these Groups. These women, the majority of whom live in remote rural areas, deserve to be celebrated. Despite the innumerable obstacles stacked against them, including poverty, illiteracy, and discrimination, these women work tirelessly to provide for their families and to give their children a better future. It is one of… Read More
-
ILO says much more needs to be done to tackle forced labour +
The International Labour Organisation (ILO) is considering its next move to tackle forced labour following publication of a new global estimate of the scale of the problem which revealed that the problem was more pervasive than previous data suggested. Illegal profits from forced labour globally are estimated at $44 billion, while the broader social and economic costs in terms of impeding economic development and perpetuating poverty have yet to be determined. A Committee of Experts has identified nine key areas for discussion by the ILO governing body at its 317th Session starting today (6 March) with the intention of agreeing a new standard at the International Labour Conference in June 2014. According to the ILO 'Forced labour encompasses brick kiln workers trapped in a vicious… Read More
-
How far will you go to help free India's Dalits? +
Have you been itching to do something that will make a difference for India’s Dalits, but not sure what? Are you fit and active? Then we have some great opportunities lined-up for supporters to do sponsored walks, runs or bike-rides. Ranging from 50k walks to 100k runs, or night-time bike rides, you can raise money for Dalit Freedom Network through a selection of actionchallenge events. Whether you do it on your own or as part of a team, all the money you raise for DFN UK will be used in our work to bring an end to the human trafficking and slavery of India’s Dalits. Are you up for the challenge? Do you want to make a real difference while experiencing the thrill of achieving?… Read More
-
India moves swiftly on violence against women, but will it help Dalits? +
The Indian government has responded swiftly to the outcry over the recent Delhi gangrape by implementing many of the recommendations by the Verma Committee. The Criminal Law (Amendment) Ordinance 2013 was implemented by the Indian President with the support of the government last weekend, but it will need to be ratified by the Parliament (which is currently in recess) within the next six months. The move has been widely welcomed, although some women’s groups have criticised the failure to enact all the report’s recommendations. The committee chaired by former Chief Justice J S Verma had produced a far-reaching and thorough review of shortcomings in both law and enforcement related to violence against women. Women’s groups and activists welcomed the report as it criticised government and… Read More
-
UN trafficking survey skewed by lack of data from India +
Child trafficking is on the increase according to the United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime (UNODC) in the first of its biennial reports on global human trafficking published at the end of December 2012. Between 2007 and 2010, child trafficking rose from 20% to 27%, a trend described as ‘worrying’. Women account for 55-60% of trafficking victims, and together with girls make up three quarters of all those trafficked. Other trends evident in the report include the doubling of trafficking for forced labour over four years. UNODC claims that over a quarter of global trafficking is domestic, but Dalit Freedom Network UK argues that this is under-estimated because of lack of data from India. A spokesperson for DFN UK said, “While the report accurately… Read More
- 1