India finally ratifies UN Trafficking Protocol

dalit childAfter an eleven-year delay, India finally ratified the UN protocol on human trafficking on 5 May 2011, along with conventions against internationally organised crime and corruption.

Known as the Palermo Protocol, the Protocol to Prevent, Suppress and Punish Trafficking in Persons, Especially Women and Children, supplementing the United Nations Convention against Transnational Organised Crime, was adopted by a UN resolution in 2000 and signed by India in 2002. The Protocol is significant because it gave the first comprehensive definition of human trafficking, and required countries to criminalise the practice, and to adopt legislation to translate the Protocol’s obligations into national law.

Year-on-year, the annual Trafficking in Persons Report has highlighted that India had failed to ratify the Protocol, as had a recent UN report[1]. The concern has been that India lacked a comprehensive definition of human trafficking to provide a common platform for the different Indian states to use in legislation and enforcement. The UN report also expressed concern that there was a shortfall in gender sensitivity. Trafficking has not been regarded as an organised crime, so provisions relevant to such crime are not  utilised in enforcement. Also, legislation and enforcement has often failed to distinguish between the trafficker and the victims, so survivors are often punished rather than perpetrators. The hope is that now these will begin to be put right.

Ratification welcomed by NGOs

Experts in child issues agree that the government announcement is a good thing. For example, in a news release, R.S. Chaurasia of child rights NGO Bachpan Bachao Andolan said: “This ratification is a shot in the arm for all the anti-human trafficking activists like us as the lack of a comprehensive legislation and policy in India has often been the reason for the lack of law enforcement and knowledge on the issue.”

“Ratification of this convention means that it is now binding upon India to develop a law that conforms to the International Convention and its provisions. Often, the criminal gangs involved in large-scale kidnappings, abductions and forced labour of children go scot-free as the laws in the country are more biased towards prosecuting the employers or pimps in case of prostitution. But traffickers of forced labour will now come within the purview of the law in the country,” he added.

Corruption fears

The lack of effective prosecutions and enforcement has been blamed at least in part on corruption, so the announcement made at the same time that India has also ratified the UN Convention Against Corruption has been welcomed. Prime Minister Manmohan Singh said “the ratification of the United Nations Convention Against Corruption is a reaffirmation of our government’s commitment to fight corruption”. Press reports highlight accusations against various sitting politicians of scams running into billions of dollars, and the end of the eleven-year wait for ratification has been put down to domestic pressure. However, the constant threat of India being downgraded to Tier 3 in the annual Trafficking in Persons report may also have had a bearing.

Dr Joseph D’souza, International President of Dalit Freedom Network, comments, “We welcome this move by the Indian government. Now we are looking for a significant improvement in enforcement and victim care as words are translated into action. Our concern is for millions of Dalits who are being exploited. They make up to 90% of all those trafficked or in bonded labour in India. We value the role of the international community not only in supporting our on-the-ground efforts to address trafficking in India, but also in encouraging the authorities to move toward more comprehensive measures and more effective action.”

Read the British government's response to India's ratification of the protocol.

[1] Responses to Human Trafficking in Bangladesh, India, Nepal and Sri Lanka (UNODC/UN.GIFT: 2011)

Latest News Articles

  • Joginis celebrate employment opportunities +

    Over 500 Joginis – Dalit women who have been forced into ritual sex slavery – are celebrating the good news that they will have opportunities to earn money through a government employment scheme. The scheme is designed to help India’s poorest, but despite living in extreme poverty, Joginis have found it difficult to access the benefits. Now, thanks to cooperation between Dalit Freedom Network’s Indian colleagues and the Telangana state project manager for the scheme, successful employment applications are being made in dozens of local government offices.   Help from the government The Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Act (MGNREGA) introduced one of a number of government schemes to help address poverty in India. The MGNREGA scheme issues employment cards that guarantee one hundred days of Read More
  • Help Make Fashion Traffik-Free: Ask #whomademyclothes? +

    Two years on from the Rana Plaza factory collapse where 1,129 people were killed, campaigners claim that very little has changed to improve conditions for workers within garment factories and across the whole fashion supply chain. Dalit Freedom Network UK is calling on supporters to mark Fashion Revolution Day by highlighting the issue human trafficking into clothing industry supply chains in southern India In Tamil Nadu, India over 200,000 young women and girls are trafficked to work in garment factories through the Sumangali Scheme. Six out of every ten are Dalits. The garments they work on end up in the shops on UK high streets. Make Fashion Traffik-Free, supported by Dalit Freedom Network UK, is calling for this exploitation to end. Around the world from Read More
  • Joginis aspire to good health and access to employment +

    A three day gathering organised by Dalit Freedom Network UK’s Indian colleagues for many of the Joginis among whom they are working celebrated progress but also revealed the extent of the problems they face. It was an opportunity for 92 Joginis to get away from the pressures they face day-to-day and to reflect on the changes that they have experienced through the support and help they receive through the DFN-supported programmes. The highlight of the gathering was a commitment from state government officials to give them access to rural employment schemes. The women also took part in a survey to evaluate the effectiveness of our programmes, and received medical check-ups and treatment. ‘Jogini’ is the local name for Dalit women and girls who have been Read More
  • Dalit women ‘Make It Happen’ for International Women’s Day +

    Dalit Freedom Network-supported LAMP groups across India have been marking International Women’s Day this month. While this year’s theme of ‘Make It Happen’ may have focused on significant achievements politically, socially and economically, for the thousands of poor and often uneducated women in these groups their grassroots achievements are no less meaningful. From Odisha to Gujarat gatherings of several hundred women at a time celebrated the role of women in their families and in society by hearing inspirational accounts of women running businesses, being a mother and being a student.   Empowerment is key In addition to the mutual support and encouragement that women find in their LAMP self-help groups, many of them receive LAMP grants which enable them to set up a small business Read More
  • Empowering marginalised women in India +

    As the world marks International Women’s Day, Dalit Freedom Network’s Indian colleagues are working hard on behalf of some of India’s most marginalised and stigmatised women – the Joginis of Telangana. Joginis are Dalit women and girls who have been forced into a form of ritual sex slavery or temple prostitution. In addition to performing duties around the village temple, the girls have to make themselves available to any man who approaches them for sexual favours. Most Joginis are uneducated and illiterate, living in extreme poverty, stigmatised in the community as women, Dalits and Joginis. They have no husband since they are ‘married’ to a goddess through a dedication ceremony and this makes it very difficult to get hold of ration cards, access to a range Read More
  • UK strengthens measures to tackle slavery in global supply chains +

    The British Government has strengthened measures to tackle modern slavery in global supply chains of large companies, but have resisted calls to go further. They have also refused to respond to demands to take the global aspect of modern slavery more seriously through requiring the new Independent Anti-Slavery Commissioner to monitor this aspect. Amendments made to the Modern Slavery Bill in the House of Lords now go back to the House of Commons for their approval on 17 March. A spokesperson for Dalit Freedom Network UK said, “We welcome the progress that has been made. Although we wanted the Government to go a lot further, it is a significant improvement on their initial position of relying on a voluntary code for businesses. We want to Read More
  • Dalit children rescued from bonded labour in bangle factories +

    Over the last few days, hundreds of children have been rescued from bangle factories in Hyderabad, the state capital of Telangana in southern India. Police were cracking down on known criminals in the lead up to India’s Republic Day celebrations when they first came across the children living and working in dangerous and unhealthy conditions. 220 children were rescued, but subsequent operations have found dozens more, including many under the age of ten, some as young as six years old. Many of the children had been trafficked from the impoverished north Indian states of Bihar and Uttar Pradesh, particularly from the poorest Dalit communities such as the Musahars and Mahadalits. They complained of being forced to work for 16 hours every day without a break, Read More
  • Microbusinesses empower 126 Dalit women to leave ritual sex slavery +

    The latest phase of Dalit Freedom Network’s economic empowerment programme* for India’s Joginis (Dalit women and girls forced into ritual sex slavery) has been rolled out in the last few months of 2014. The programme aims to build on and improve the initial pilot phase by ensuring that each microbusiness venture will provide enough income to cover the livelihoods of all those taking part. The pilot showed the value of microbusinesses in helping to restore the dignity of women who otherwise found it difficult to shed the stigma of their position in society and the sexual exploitation to which they are subjected. It also demonstrated that more had to be done to ensure sufficient income. 126 women from various villages in Telangana state are benefitting from the Read More
  • India's Joginis face highest rate of HIV-AIDS +

    Dedicated as a Jogini when only seven years old, Jayamma* was ‘deflowered’ as soon as she reached puberty. By 13, she was pregnant but had no idea who the father was, as she had been used by most of the men in the village. When her uncle, who had used her for many years, died from AIDS, the reason for Jayamma’s frequent sickness and increasing weakness through her 20s became clear. Taken to the regional hospital by Dalit Freedom Network’s Indian colleagues, Jayamma was diagnosed as HIV positive. Her story illustrates the severe threat to the lives of women trapped in the Jogini system of ritual sex slavery in India.   High vulnerability to HIV-AIDS Jayamma’s story is presented as a case study in the influential Read More
  • A measure of success for Dalit Education Centres +

    What happens to students after they finish school in our Dalit Education Centres is critical to evaluating the success of Dalit Freedom Network’s education programme in India. A recent survey of school leavers from one of the first Dalit Education Centres to be established showed that nine out of ten were continuing in higher education. This is a huge boost to the tens of thousands of pupils from Dalit communities and other poor and marginalised backgrounds who are benefitting from quality English-medium education in over one hundred DFN-supported schools across India.   Preventing Dalit trafficking and slavery Education is one of the key elements in DFN’s trafficking prevention work. DFN’s Indian partners believe that thirty to forty per cent of pupils would be trafficked or Read More
  • 1